Intraday trading vs position trading: what is the difference?
Both are ways of trading shares. What changes is how long the trade stays open, how much watching it needs, what can go wrong, and how much tax each trade pays. Here is the difference, using only what SEBI and NSE have published.
Published 18 November 2026 · Potoos Research Services
The short answer. An intraday trade is opened and closed in the same trading session. If it is still open near the close, the broker may close it for you. A position trade (also called positional trading) is carried overnight and held for days, weeks or longer. In shares, that means a delivery trade: the shares come into your demat account. So intraday trading needs your attention while the market is open, but nothing is left open overnight. Position trading needs less watching during the day, but the trade stays open while the market is shut, when news can move the price before you can act. The tax on each trade differs too. STT, the Securities Transaction Tax, is 0.025% on the sale in an intraday equity trade, and 0.1% on both the purchase and the sale in a delivery trade, as listed in NSE's circular of 31 March 2026. Neither style is free of risk. Both carry market risk. SEBI's own study found that 71% of individual intraday traders in the equity cash segment made a net loss in FY 2022-23.
The two side by side
- How long the trade is open. Intraday: opened and closed within one trading session. Position: carried overnight, for days, weeks or longer. These are trading labels, not legal categories, and people draw the lines in slightly different places.
- Attention needed. Intraday: decisions happen while the market is open, often several in a session. Position: the plan can be made outside market hours, with reviews on a schedule.
- Margin. Intraday trades often run on margin, money the broker blocks from your account to cover the trade. SEBI's rules require that margin to be collected upfront and check it at several points in the day (see below). A delivery trade is settled by paying for the shares and receiving them in your demat account.
- What can go wrong. Intraday: many small decisions, costs on every trade, and a forced close if the position is still open at the broker's cut-off. Position: overnight gaps, where the next session opens far from the last close and a stop-loss cannot act while the market is shut.
- Tax per trade (STT). Intraday equity: 0.025% on the sale only. Delivery: 0.1% on the purchase and 0.1% on the sale. Details below.
Margin: what SEBI's peak margin rules changed for intraday
SEBI first required brokers in the cash segment to collect upfront VaR margin and ELM from clients in its circular of 19 November 2019. VaR margin and ELM (extreme loss margin) are two margins the clearing corporation sets for each share, to cover its likely and its extreme price moves. Market participants then raised issues in putting this into practice, so SEBI set up a way to verify it, in circular SEBI/HO/MRD2/DCAP/CIR/P/2020/127, dated 20 July 2020 and in force from 1 December 2020:
- The clearing corporation sends brokers at least 4 snapshots a day of each client's margin requirement, taken at random within set time windows.
- The broker reports two numbers for each client: the margin collected at the end of the day, and the peak margin collected during the day, across the snapshots.
- Both are compared with what was required. The higher of the two shortfalls is penalised.
- The peak check was brought in step by step: 25% of the peak requirement for the first 3 months, then 50%, then 75%, then 100%.
SEBI's circular says it plainly: "the applicable upfront margins are required to be collected from the clients in advance of the trade." For an intraday trader, this means the margin is measured at the busiest point of the day, not only at the close. Each broker also sets its own cut-off time for closing open intraday positions, and its own charge for doing so. Those are in your broker's terms, so read them there.
Overnight risk: what position trading adds
A position trade stays open after the session closes, and through weekends and market holidays. Company results, policy decisions and overseas markets can all move while Indian markets are shut. When trading resumes, a share can open well above or below its last close. This is called a gap. A stop-loss order (an order to exit if the price reaches a level you set) cannot be filled while the market is closed, so after a gap it may be filled far from the level you chose. If a position is held through futures rather than delivered shares, margin is checked at the end of every day it stays open, as in the framework above.
Costs: STT on each style
NSE's circular 02/2026 (NSE/FATAX/73524, 31 March 2026) lists the STT rates that apply from 1 April 2026, after the Finance Act, 2026. For shares, the rates did not change.
- Intraday equity, on the sale
- 0.025%
- Delivery, on the purchase
- 0.1%
- Delivery, on the sale
- 0.1%
- Futures, on the sale
- 0.05%
Futures rose from 0.02% to 0.05% from 1 April 2026. Worked example, arithmetic on these rates only: Rs 1,00,000 of shares, opened and closed at the same price. An intraday trade pays Rs 25 in STT, on the sale. A delivery trade pays Rs 100 on the purchase and Rs 100 on the sale, Rs 200 in all.
A lower STT per trade does not mean lower costs in total. STT is one line on your contract note, next to brokerage, exchange charges, stamp duty and GST, and every line repeats with every trade. The more trades you make, the more often each of these charges is paid.
What SEBI found when it studied intraday traders
SEBI Press Release No. 13/2024, dated 24 July 2024, summarised SEBI's study of individual intraday traders in the equity cash segment. The study covered FY 2018-19, FY 2021-22 and FY 2022-23. It used a sample of individual clients of the top 10 stock brokers, around 86% of the individual client count in the equity cash segment in FY 2022-23. A working group from academia, brokers and market experts peer reviewed it. Its findings:
- 7 out of 10 individual intraday traders (71%) made a net loss in FY 2022-23.
- Among very frequent traders, with more than 500 trades in a year, the share of loss-makers rose to 80%.
- Among traders under 30 years of age, 76% were loss-makers, higher than in other age groups. Their share of all intraday traders grew to 48% in FY 2022-23, from 18% in FY 2018-19.
- On top of their trading losses, loss-makers spent an additional 57% of those losses on trading costs. Profit-makers spent 19% of their profits on trading costs.
- Around 1 in 3 individuals who trade in the equity cash segment trades intraday, and their number rose over 300% from FY 2018-19 to FY 2022-23.
The study covers intraday traders only. SEBI's release gives no matching figure for people who hold positions for days or weeks, so it does not show that position trading loses less. Position trades carry market risk too.
Questions to ask yourself before either style
Can I watch the market while it is open?
Intraday decisions happen during market hours. If your day job does not allow that, an open intraday trade may end up closed at the broker's cut-off instead.
Can I accept a move I cannot react to?
A position trade will sit through nights, weekends and holidays. Decide in advance how big an overnight move you can carry.
Do I know my full cost per trade?
Add up every line on one contract note, then multiply by the number of trades you expect in a month.
Do I have a written exit plan?
For both styles, write the exit level and the reason before the trade, not after.
For more on holding a trade for weeks, our page on positional trading vs swing and intraday covers planning a positional trade, what can go wrong while you hold, and how gains are taxed. It also explains why you can lose money on a right call.
Sources
- SEBI Press Release No. 13/2024, study of individual intraday traders in the equity cash segment. 24 July 2024. Page 1, study period, sample and peer review; pages 1 to 2, the list of major findings.
- SEBI circular SEBI/HO/MRD2/DCAP/CIR/P/2020/127, framework to enable verification of upfront collection of margins from clients in cash and derivatives segments. 20 July 2020. Page 1, paragraph 2 (the 19 November 2019 circular); page 2, paragraphs 5 and 7; page 3, Annexure points (i) to (iii); pages 3 to 4, phased adoption.
- NSE circular 02/2026 (NSE/FATAX/73524), changes in relation to rates of Securities Transaction Tax. 31 March 2026. Page 1, revised derivatives rates (a) to (c); pages 1 to 2, the rate table, rows 1, 2, 3 and 4(c).
- SEBI list of registered research analysts, the official register.
Data source: the data on this page is referenced from NSE (National Stock Exchange of India), nseindia.com, and SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India), sebi.gov.in. The documents are linked in the Sources list above. None of these sources has reviewed or approved this page.
Sources checked on 17 November 2026. Information cutoff: 17 November 2026, 13:00 IST
Common questions
What is the difference between intraday trading and position trading?
An intraday trade is opened and closed in the same trading session. A position trade is carried overnight and held for days, weeks or longer; in shares it is a delivery trade, so the shares come into your demat account. Intraday needs attention during market hours. Position trading leaves the trade open while the market is shut.
Is intraday trading riskier than position trading?
Neither style is safe; both carry market risk. The risks differ. SEBI's study found that 71% of individual intraday traders in the equity cash segment made a net loss in FY 2022-23. Position trades carry overnight gap risk, where the next session opens far from the last close. SEBI's release gives no matching loss figure for position traders.
How much STT is paid on intraday and delivery trades?
Per NSE's circular of 31 March 2026, STT on an intraday equity trade is 0.025% on the sale, paid by the seller. On a delivery trade it is 0.1% on the purchase and 0.1% on the sale. On the sale of futures it is 0.05% from 1 April 2026.
What is peak margin?
Under SEBI's framework in force from 1 December 2020, the clearing corporation takes at least 4 snapshots a day of each client's margin requirement. The highest of these is the peak margin. Brokers must have collected it upfront, and a shortfall against the peak or the end-of-day requirement draws a penalty.
Who did SEBI's intraday study cover?
Individual clients of the top 10 stock brokers, around 86% of the individual client count in the equity cash segment in FY 2022-23. It covered FY 2018-19, FY 2021-22 and FY 2022-23, and was peer reviewed by a working group from academia, brokers and market experts.
Potoos Research, SEBI-registered Research Analyst. Registration number INH000027380. SEBI is the Securities and Exchange Board of India.
